Random Prime Video Mystery Movie Wheel

Spin to pick a random mystery movie streaming on Prime Video in the US right now. Well-rated titles only, with availability refreshed daily from JustWatch.

up to 200 of 559

Random Prime Video Mystery Movie Wheel

1Silver City
2The Poughkeepsie Tapes
3Unacknowledged
4Fletch
5Like Minds
6Magellan
7Damascus Cover
8The Priests
9Kept Woman
106 Souls
11Boogeyman
12Donovan's Echo
13Xeno
14The Paperboy
15Nancy
16The Execution
17The Bird with the Crystal Plumage
18Dressed to Kill
19AfterDeath
20Last Man Down
21Sweet Sixteen
22The Lie
23Kit Kittredge: An American Girl
24Without a Paddle
25Ghost Train
Showing 25 of 30 items. Scroll for more
Tabletop random spin wheel with colored slices on a stand
Spin it for realTabletop random spin wheels
Shop spin wheels
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

30 movies on this wheeldrawn from 559 β€” regenerate for a new set

  • Silver CitySilver City
  • The Poughkeepsie TapesThe Poughkeepsie Tapes
  • UnacknowledgedUnacknowledged
  • FletchFletch
  • Like MindsLike Minds
  • MagellanMagellan
  • Damascus CoverDamascus Cover
  • The PriestsThe Priests
  • Kept WomanKept Woman
  • 6 Souls6 Souls
  • BoogeymanBoogeyman
  • Donovan's EchoDonovan's Echo
  • XenoXeno
  • The PaperboyThe Paperboy
  • NancyNancy
  • The ExecutionThe Execution
  • The Bird with the Crystal PlumageThe Bird with the Crystal Plumage
  • Dressed to KillDressed to Kill
  • AfterDeathAfterDeath
  • Last Man DownLast Man Down
  • Sweet SixteenSweet Sixteen
  • The LieThe Lie
  • Kit Kittredge: An American GirlKit Kittredge: An American Girl
  • Without a PaddleWithout a Paddle
  • Ghost TrainGhost Train
  • ShutterShutter
  • The ImposterThe Imposter
  • The Diary of Ellen RimbauerThe Diary of Ellen Rimbauer
  • Cutting ClassCutting Class
  • CubeCube

Ways to use this wheel

Get your Prime Video money's worth

Spin a mystery movie already included with Prime Video and put the subscription to use tonight.

Whodunit night

Spin a mystery movie on Prime Video and pause before the reveal for everyone's guess.

Detective scorecard

Spin a few mystery movies and keep score of who solves each one first.

Make the most of a Prime Video trial

On a Prime Video trial, spin its best-rated mystery movies and watch a few before the trial ends.

Mystery movies club

Take turns spinning a mystery movie on Prime Video each week, then rate it together.

Mystery double feature

Spin twice and watch two mystery movies on Prime Video back to back.

About the random Prime Video Mystery Movie Wheel

Let the wheel pick a mystery movie to watch on Prime Video. Every title here is streaming on Prime Video in the US right now as part of the subscription (no rentals or purchases), drawn from 559 well-rated mystery movies on the service. Availability comes from JustWatch and refreshes daily, so a title that just left may linger for a day.

Narrow it to a decade below, try another genre on Prime Video, or switch services.