Random MLB Role Player Catcher Wheel

Spin to pick a random MLB role player catcher from any era: players who never made an All-Star team, won a major award, or reached the Hall of Fame. A free deep-cut MLB player wheel with photos.

up to 200 of 1,330

Random MLB Role Player Catcher Wheel

1Sam Hairston
2Dan Mahoney
3Hal Finney
4Billy Shantz
5Harry Smith
6Josh Phegley
7Joe Ayrault
8Hobie Landrith
9Raymond Haley
10Benny Culp
11Bob Roselli
12Kyle Phillips
13Billy Sullivan Jr.
14Bruno Block
15Russ Gibson
16Bill Ludwig
17Gus Sandberg
18Drew Romo
19Tim McIntosh
20Ossee Schreckengost
21Peaches O'Neill
22Nick Testa
23Dalton Rushing
24Rick Sweet
25Earl Averill, Jr.
Showing 25 of 32 items. Scroll for more
Tabletop random spin wheel with colored slices on a stand
Spin it for realTabletop random spin wheels
Shop spin wheels
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

32 catchers on this wheeldrawn from 1,330 โ€” regenerate for a new set

  • Sam Hairston
  • Dan MahoneyDan Mahoney
  • Hal Finney
  • Billy ShantzBilly Shantz
  • Harry Smith
  • Josh PhegleyJosh Phegley
  • Joe Ayrault
  • Hobie LandrithHobie Landrith
  • Raymond Haley
  • Benny Culp
  • Bob Roselli
  • Kyle PhillipsKyle Phillips
  • Billy Sullivan Jr.
  • Bruno Block
  • Russ GibsonRuss Gibson
  • Bill LudwigBill Ludwig
  • Gus Sandberg
  • Drew RomoDrew Romo
  • Tim McIntoshTim McIntosh
  • Ossee SchreckengostOssee Schreckengost
  • Peaches O'Neill
  • Nick Testa
  • Dalton RushingDalton Rushing
  • Rick SweetRick Sweet
  • Earl Averill, Jr.Earl Averill, Jr.
  • Andy Dominique
  • Rich RowlandRich Rowland
  • Ben Petrick
  • Mike RoarkeMike Roarke
  • Steve Decker
  • Andy SeminickAndy Seminick
  • Eddie MaloneEddie Malone

Ways to use this wheel

All-time MLB catchers draft

Take turns spinning MLB role player catchers, draft your top three each, then argue about who won.

Deep-cut MLB trivia

Spin an MLB role player catcher and see who in the room still remembers them.

MLB card hunt

Spin an MLB role player catcher and track down one of their cards.

Guess the era

Spin an MLB role player catcher and name the decade they played.

MLB The Show catcher challenge

Spin an MLB role player catcher and you have to use them in your next MLB The Show game.

Guess the MLB role player catcher

Photo-only mode: name the MLB role player catcher before the wheel stops.

About the random MLB Role Player Catcher Wheel

Let the wheel pick from MLB role players. This wheel holds 1,330 role players from every MLB franchise at catcher. These are the players who never made an All-Star team, won a major award, or reached the Hall of Fame: the deep cuts of MLB history.

Try all-time players, another tier, or pick a team.